Fake or Photo

A fun little challenge.

I got 9 out of 12.

http://area.autodesk.com/index.php/fakeorfoto/challenge/

11 out of 12. Got the bulb wrong.

Shitty use of depth of focus gave most of the others away.

Ya, i missed the lightbulb, the gavel, and can’t remember the other…I think the spanner.

9/12. Missed the clock, gavel and shelf.

10\12

Got the glass, and pull chord wrong

Missed the blinds… I swear I’ve seen that image before as a rendering. I remember taking this test 5 or 6 years ago and it was much easier to tell CG vs Photo.

Just like bobcat, the bulb fooled me.

I found it hard to make the call on the blinds -I couldn’t make up my mind whether that was planned inconsistency or natural. It was 50-50 and I got lucky.

10 out of 12

I missed the bridge and the pull cord.

I would love to Model that bridge. but halfway through the project i would probably start to loathe its existence.

12/12!
all lucky guesses, those renders are crazy!

11/12

I got the door wrong, haha. It was suspiciously over-textured to me.

11/12

I missed the blinds for the same reason as Paul

11/12

The blinds got me, but I can’t remember what I selected. I think I picked CG, because of the strange glow around the chord…

Same as above 11/12 missed the blinds.

10/12, blinds and gavel. The lighting just doesnt look right on those blinds, almost like there is an artificial ghosting going on.

12/12, i reckon the gavel, door and blinds could have been either though.

11/12 the glass. Idk, it looked fake, I just thought “too fake, must be real”

10/12 Those damn blinds! The colors on the door looked somewhat artificial too.

12/12!!

That was tough… spend enough time looking through the lens though, and you will know the subtle differences…

10|12 .the bulb got me, could’ve sworn the filament looked very CG!

10/12

Blinds and Bridge got me.

The bridge felt like a trick question so I guessed CG.