Richard: note that the shut line on the old Z4 continues past the light and bumper and into the door shut line. That’s why that car is genius. Nothing that wasn’t consciously decided.
The old 5 series shut line is more resolved, or at least more hidden. Kinda unforgivable to over look these details on a $50k+ luxury car brand known for design.
I think the new one is a very handsome and refined design. Funny enough, everyone accuses the new 5 of being “simpler” and more conservative than the previous one. The new 5 is busier and has much more linework, but I think it comes off as simpler because all of the lines work together very well. It’s a very consistent design all around.
I do get the impression that this 5 takes less risks than the previous one. I also wish the new 5 and 7 were more different from each other.
Really like the new 5-series, the lines work much better then the old generation, especially the front and headlights are finally improved. The old 5 looked a bit a stranger in between the new 3, X1 and 7 designs. I’am happy in Europe we don’t have such wheels…