Rogue One Discussions: SPOILER ALERT!

You are totally right about Krennic’s ship. Something about that was bothering me. Instead of being in the vein of the originals it was more of a cartoon representation of it. I thought Vader’s Castle was a little too Dr Evil as well.

By contrast it was great to see them using the same old rebel base (what does that guy do up in the crow’s nest with the binoculars? Don’t these guys have radar?) and I thought the empirical cargo shuttle was spot on!