Have you considered the Mercedes-Benz SLK? Might be a little bit old dude for you but there is no denying it’s a solid ride.
From the Consumer Reports review: “The SLK delivers top-down motoring without the usual convertible compromises of poor rear visibility and pronounced wind noise. It features an electrically retractable hard top that stows in the trunk but limits cargo room. The seats are very comfortable, and the head restraints feature optional neck-level vents that blow warm air. Our tested SLK350 had a strong 3.5-liter V6 with a sporty engine note. The manual shifter and clutch are user-friendly. Handling is agile, yet the ride is relatively comfortable. Reliability has been average.”