Close

Industrial Design Schools: Opinions and Questions

Postby yo » December 2nd, 2004, 10:39 am

User avatar

yo
Administration
Administration
 
Posts: 16304
Joined: January 5th, 2004, 6:57 pm
Location: SoCal
The questions of what school should I go to, what schools are the best, can you rank the top 5 schools.... seem to come up weekly, so I thought we could start this thread as a place to contain insight on undergraduate and graduate Industrial Design programs around the world.

Please post your questions and opinions in hear so we can keep a running resource going. Keep in ming that the information on the programs, as allways, will be highly biased and is no substitute for visiting the schools and comparing them yourself. It will be good suplemental information I hope.

Postby yo » December 2nd, 2004, 10:46 am

User avatar

yo
Administration
Administration
 
Posts: 16304
Joined: January 5th, 2004, 6:57 pm
Location: SoCal
I'll kick it off with some opinions of my own:

Best US schools for core product design (electronics, consumer goods, general design firm type stuff) as well as specialties like: Transportation, Toys, Footwear

University of Cincinatti- good price, great co-op program, respected
Art Center College of Design- rigorous program, great reputation, good alumni network
Cleveland Institute of Art- relatively cheap, caring faculty, stresses profesionalism, visiting instructors from Detroit.
College for Creative Studies- highly networked into auto industry.
Columbus College of Art and Design- great value for the money program
Academy of Art College- up and coming program
Pratt- In New York, stresses artistic side of design

Best Schools for Theory based grad programs:
Cranbrook
RISD

Anybody got more info on programs, or anything to add about schools outside the US? or schools for Furniture? Throw it down
Last edited by yo on December 6th, 2004, 10:33 am, edited 1 time in total.

Postby dow317 » December 2nd, 2004, 12:21 pm


dow317
step three
step three
 
Posts: 138
Joined: October 25th, 2004, 6:58 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA
I think it's really cool that you are so involved in the community. I always appreciate your comments. Kudos to you.

If I had to pick a grad school, I would definately choose


Art Center or Pratt. The alumni work coming out of those two programs is just mind blowing. I also like the emersive atmosphere I hear about.

Postby PovD@wg » December 2nd, 2004, 9:20 pm

User avatar

PovD@wg
step three
step three
 
Posts: 100
Joined: September 28th, 2004, 2:46 pm
Location: St. Louis / Chicago
I always appreciate your comments. Kudos to you.

I second that! YO, you definitely Rock! Thanx for all the great stuff!

Postby yo » December 3rd, 2004, 1:50 am

User avatar

yo
Administration
Administration
 
Posts: 16304
Joined: January 5th, 2004, 6:57 pm
Location: SoCal
...uhm, thanks guys. :roll: us moderators don't get paid for this gig, so thank you.


so any thoughts or questions on good schools? ... or maybe bad schools?

Postby bearcat » December 3rd, 2004, 8:33 am

User avatar

bearcat
step four
step four
 
Posts: 219
Joined: January 8th, 2004, 8:34 am
Location: Happy Hands Club
Alright, I'll chime in. As an alumni of University of Cincinnati, my vote would be for UC. I've said it before in other posts, but you really can't beat their co-op program. Sure, other schools 'allow' you to take internships, but UC requires you. At the end of the day, you graduate with 6 quarters (a year and half) of real world experience under your belt. UC has longstanding co-op relationships with some of the worlds top companies: Motorola, Nike, GM, Chrysler, Ford, Fisher Price, P&G, etc.

During my day, I guess it could be said that some of the teaching staff were a bit on the 'old' side...still teaching gouche rendering skills, etc. That's been changing over the past few years, with the addition of a couple new professors. Recently, UC hired Craig Vogel from Carnegie Mellon to head up UC's new design research department.

It's really hard to evaluate which school is the 'best.' On a dollar for dollar comparasion, though, UC would be hard to beat. And to be honest, just because you're shelling out big bucks for Art Center, doesn't guarantee that you'll be designing Ferrari's in Italy! If you're talented and passionate about design, you'll flourish at any one of these schools!
Last edited by bearcat on December 3rd, 2004, 10:50 am, edited 1 time in total.

Postby FortuneCookie » December 3rd, 2004, 9:27 am


FortuneCookie
step one
step one
 
Posts: 32
Joined: March 29th, 2004, 9:40 pm
I graduated from RIT and have been following changes made to the program and it is really coming along nicely

RIT's program stresses functionality and you get plenty of opportunities to learn whatever 3d modeling program you're into. RIT also has the School of American Crafts, which is highly rated, so if you are into furniture you can couple furniture and woodworking classes with your ID courses. They also offer ceramics, metals, glass blowing, and all that stuff

They've also recently started working with the engineers on campus. RIT's engineering program is HUGE so there is a lot of opportunity there too, not only to learn from another discipline but also to teach the engineers what ID is all about.

schools

Postby Dionysus » December 3rd, 2004, 2:33 pm


Dionysus
 
I graduated from Pratt's undergrad, and am going to be undertaking studies at
art center in january. Pratt will blow your mind if you have one, they have a really solid theoretical approach to both process and 3d aesthetics, however not a lot on the analog presentation skills end, they're way to heavy on the Alias to make up for poor drawing ability. I'm going to AC to blow up my presentation ability and to get a more solid handle on rapid prototyping technologies and advance model-building technique, although I didn't notice a lot of substantive ideas behind all of the glamour which the school is well known for. Anyway, that's my take.

Postby nobody special » December 3rd, 2004, 4:57 pm


nobody special
 
yo,
perhaps you could cull through and link to some of the more valuable threads you referred to...?

Postby BDP » December 4th, 2004, 1:41 pm


BDP
 
I'd say in general the best place to learn about design is outside of the classroom. Students today need to make sure they invest more time into obsorbing the real world around them, because someday that will be your client.

Having said that, it's equally important to employers that students coming out of school have a very strong skills set. You have to be able to communicate your ideas in a clear and compelling manner. Remember, in the real world you usually are presenting to non-designers.

Art Center is one school that definately has the curriculm to get you there, but you have to work hard at it. And the location is ideal because there is so much to do around you, but you have to find time to get out there and experience it. Also the alumni network is the strongest aout there

There are other schools out there that are well respected, CCS, RCA, Strate, Florzhiem, Coventry, Cincinatti and Art Acadamy, etc... I would encourage you to visit as many as possible, take all apects into account and pick the one that most inspires you.

I've worked at IDEO and Nike and I've learned that if you want to have a great job in design, you have to make the most the of your education, because you don't want to graduate and wish you had a better portfolio.

Postby yo » December 4th, 2004, 3:10 pm

User avatar

yo
Administration
Administration
 
Posts: 16304
Joined: January 5th, 2004, 6:57 pm
Location: SoCal

Postby Scott Digital » December 6th, 2004, 10:25 am


Scott Digital
 
YO makes probably the best overall comments on each of the 6 schools he comments on.

Everyone is going to say "I went to so and so and it is the best". I truely feel there is only one way to choose.

1st find what academia (and design professionals) think are the best three to five schools. (NOT what are going to be the best, because that means that they are not)

just off the top of my head

CCS, CIA, Art Center, Cincinati. all top notch schools

Visit these schools and talk to the students and see their work. Look at the facilities (not how pretty the building is) but at the resoursessss, who teaches there, what does the faculty do in it's spare time, where are graduates working (AND every college exagerates it's claims "everyone gets a job" B.S.)What is the teacher to student ratio, and how many people make it through the program and graduate.

THE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF THIS EQUATION is TALK TO THE STUDENTS.
You have to visit the school, and break off from the steralized tour. See what the students really feel because they will be honest with you.

I was told some serious lies by the faculty at a school in Columbus, they actully lied to me and said " oh yea you can do transportation design here we have a pretty good program" I went for a tour and didn't see too much trans. So I broke off from the group and started talking to students. They set me straight and said that the faculty says that to get students, but the students I spoke with actually recomended other schools to me for trans. But I was so impressed with my initial response to the beautiful modern building I was clouded by the real facts.

I could not be happier that I talked to the students and got the real story, so I passes up this school and visited three others, and made my decission bassed on what I have already stated.

OK enough already I hope this is in the smallest way helpful. Remember this is a very important decission not to be taken lightly. good luk

Scott Digital out.......

MIAD

Postby vapackerjohn » December 6th, 2004, 10:57 am


vapackerjohn
 
I am a aulmni from Milwaukee Institute of Art & Design. I put in a solid plug the school, which has grown rapidly since I have graduated. It is one of the only private ID schools in the Mid-West and is worthy of consideration.
John

Postby hitch » December 6th, 2004, 11:07 am

User avatar

hitch
step four
step four
 
Posts: 220
Joined: May 28th, 2004, 9:21 pm
Location: Portland, OR
Took a look at the links you listed Yo -- turns out I'd already seen a couple of them, but worthwhile to check again, if only to observe how quickly things turn nasty when you ask folks to list The Top 5 Schools in --.

Seems to me that the only thing everyone agrees on is that different schools have different strengths, and which one is the *best* depends on your own background and what you want to do later in life. What might actually be a much more useful discussion (if anyone else is interested in chiming in) is a specific listing of strengths and weakenesses of various design schools by people who either went there or have worked with graduates from there.

For example. I graduated in May of this year from the Pratt Master of ID program, and can offer this:

Strengths --
Very high fraction of faculty are working designers, and often discuss real world issues in class.
The 3D analysis curriculum is outstanding, and produces designers with strong innate senses of form and proportion.
3D sketch modeling is encouraged at least as much as 2D, leading to very creative forms and solutions not often seen from more "pencil-oriented" schools.
The Masters program requires extensive research and strategy work, pushing designs toward the innovative and away from the purely stylistic.
The broad range of backgrounds in the Masters program means that team projects and studio work benefit from a wide range of insights.
The Brooklyn location puts you in the middle of the largest concentration of creative professionals in North America -- chances are good that your neighbor is writer, graphic artist, documentary filmmaker, etc, so there are endless sources of inspiration.
New York holds the offices of dozens of design firms, as well as galleries and events like the ICFF, so opportunities for internships and exhibition are great.

Weaknesses --
Very expensive.
Absurdly disorganized; if a student doesn't have the drive and ability to find their own internship, build their own useful curriculum, pursue their own projects, they run the risk of learning next to nothing.
The lack of a foundation year for non-designers entering the MID program means it's possible to graduate without knowing how to draw or build a finished model.
Poor maintenance of physical resources, though this is improving.
The high fraction of working designers in the faculty means very few full-time teachers, so actual teaching ability varies wildly -- many teachers do not perform basic tasks like writing and holding to a syllabus, giving clear assignments, holding constructive critiques, etc.
Very few (if any) projects are developed to a level of finish and produceability that makes for a solid portfolio piece. Recent graduates often find themselves spending 6 months or more fixing work to make it presentable to potential employers.


Anyone else? I for one would love to see something like this for Art Center, UC, RISD, etc.[/quote]

Postby a non ee mouse » December 6th, 2004, 3:17 pm


a non ee mouse
 
University of Wisconsin - Stout hasn't had the strongest representation in the past year or two, but since the recent curriculum revision, I'd say that it is a force to be reckoned with. Faculty let students discover what sort of designers they want to be and encourage them to experiment and explore. I've noticed a significant increase in the enthusiasm of the students and their student chapter IDSA has had some very interesting activities going on currently.

Other benefits: Low tuition.

Students coming from state universities have a broader education and have the ability to take more classes that can compliment ID, such as marketing and business classes as well as psychology and sociology classes.

In the end, the quality of your education is really up to you. You get what you put into it. If you work hard and are enthusiastic about what you are doing, you will be successful.

Go to the Next Page

Return to students and schools